Wednesday, March 24, 2010

This Morning I Wrote Myself A Note

And the note was just one line. It said "on the day Adolf Hitler came to power, France had no government." It is a historical fact. France was so chaotic that on the day Adolf Hitler was named Chancellor in Germany the French government had fallen and its replacement was still "in the works". No point to it, really, just something that kept coming into my head. You know France in the 30's was a political madhouse. There was killing and fighting between the two sides that dominated French politics in those days. People died for - and what's more important to note is that people actually killed in the name of - ideas and opinions. Their own countrymen. People who spoke the same language and had the same cultural memory.

There had been a civil war in Spain in those times, Franco's Falange Party fighting against the Republicans. Brutal stuff. Each side armed by foreign powers in a kind of dress-rehearsal for what was to come later, only everybody was from the same country. You wonder how things get that out of hand.

When ideas mean more than people life gets cheap.

Someone who is a voice for one idea dies and the people of the other idea are happy. All kinds of de-humanizing language is thrown back and forth. Labels are assigned to the other side. Names. Demeaning traits. And everybody joins in. It's the average, unexceptional part of good old human nature. Not the angels part. I'm dirty with it myself.

When you stop seeing the humanity in someone it's easier to kill them.

People get caught up in the moment. Strident voices cheering this side or the other side on. Compromise is impossible because any move toward the other idea is seen as betrayal. Dogmatism trumps Pragmatism. Pragmatism carries a negative connotation. Better traits are ascribed to those who believe in the ideas expressed by your side. This idea is common sense, the other idea is goofy. This idea does the most good, the other idea ruins everything.

Bricks get thrown through windows. The sides stop talking. People start carrying guns. There is yelling, not conversation. After all how do you communicate with robots or animals or the mentally deficient?

That was France in the 30's alright. Quite a mess.

Changing gears just a little... wow, there's a big mid-term election this year. Did you know that? You know, if I was a cynical man, I'd say this was going to be a very violent year in America. I'd say someone's going to die this summer and - what's worse - someone is going to kill. I'd say it was something that had to happen because no middle ground is available to anyone. Compromise is out of the question. The idea that politics should never get in the way of our mutual defense isn't in the language anymore. There are people with ideas spoiling for a fight.

When ideas get hot, they tend to get solid.

And when communication isn't heard over all the noise, communication sometimes turns into bullets so it can't be ignored anymore. It's all over history. We duked it out once before in this country ourselves, and we STILL can't agree on what the fight was all about. And it would be a mistake for one side to think the other won't fight back. It seems everybody's ideas are solid little things right now.

But I'm not really a cynic. I'm an optimist. This is America. We drive our cars with courtesy, we listen to other people instead of just waiting for our turn to talk. We use polite language. We're better than that.

We're certainly better than France.

Aren't we?

14 Comments:

At March 24, 2010 8:17 PM , Blogger sybil law said...

No. Maybe. Hopefully.
I love this country, too - but right now, it seems like everyone's in a frothing, fucking frenzy and it's frightening.
I swear I didn't plan all those "f" words.
They were just fitting.
:)

 
At March 24, 2010 9:15 PM , Blogger Gino said...

i kinda like the idea of politicians who's main objective is to impose and steal (thats most)feeling the need to look over their shoulder every day, but still, it aint no way to run a country.

 
At March 24, 2010 9:20 PM , Blogger RW said...

Well if I were a cynic I'd say what's going to happen instead is citizens who will have to do the looking over their shoulders. From each other. Lucky I'm not a cynic huh?

 
At March 24, 2010 9:53 PM , Blogger Dave2 said...

Tonight I had dinner at the Hard Rock Cafe in Bucharest where I was seated across from a table of three American teenagers. They had to be the most foul-mouthed, idiotic, disrespectful, douchebag dumbass things I've seen since I left the USA last Friday.

No matter how bad things are now, the future is going to be much worse.

 
At March 24, 2010 10:24 PM , Blogger Gino said...

rw: in some areas, they already do.

ya know whats scary? the govt has the tech to know so much about us, its just a matter of installing the infrastructure to capture all these comments and follow up on them.
then, it wont be our shoulders we be looking over.

 
At March 24, 2010 10:35 PM , Blogger RW said...

I don't think "the government" - whoever that is - has malintent. I think the government consists of people whose main concern is re-election no matter what.

I guess I don't hear the spooky music. Who exactly in the government would be doing this to us, exactly?

 
At March 24, 2010 11:02 PM , Blogger Faiqa said...

If I weren't so incredibly vain, I would tattoo "when ideas mean more than people life gets cheap" on my FACE.

Our saving grace, not only as Americans but as human beings, is that we have the ability to see the big picture and the greater good. Our tragic flaw, of course, is that we inevitably lose sight of it.

 
At March 24, 2010 11:30 PM , Blogger Brian said...

I don't think we're better than France. But we do have the benefit of the 75 odd years of history since then. We (and by this I mean humankind) do occasionally learn from our mistakes. There is a reason that Europeans are generally so averse to militarism, for example.

 
At March 25, 2010 8:30 AM , Blogger Miss Britt said...

This is terrifying.

Reading this doesn't make me feel smug about other Americans or another political party who are CLEARLY more "idiotic" than me or mine.

It's just terrifying.

Because you're right. It's in all of us. And it's in all of us to say "yeah - THOSE people could be dangerous."

 
At March 25, 2010 8:39 AM , Anonymous Nanna said...

Jesus, this is soooo good

 
At March 25, 2010 10:06 AM , Blogger lizriz said...

This is so interesting, because I recently finished reading "The Crimes of Paris," and I was definitely struck by many similarities between France during the Belle Epoch and today's America. I also ended the book with a serious appreciation of French passion, for better or worse. :)

 
At March 25, 2010 1:59 PM , Blogger Coal Miner's Granddaughter said...

As I sit back and watch American politics and opinions in action, I'm struck by the fact that I see no unity, no Americans. What I see are Republicans and Democrats, Conservatives and Liberals, "We're Right"s and "You're Wrong"s. There's no middle, no medium, and that to me is frightening.

I remember a once-friend of mine saying "Everything is black or white. It has to be. Gray is evil and to exist in the gray is bad." I couldn't believe it. I had always felt that everything should be taken in moderation. Be it food, drink, sex, ideas, religion, or politics. Black and white absolutes are bad. Gray, the middle, the meeting point, is far better for everyone.

And I don't see us meeting in the middle. I see us polarizing and that worries me greatly.

 
At March 25, 2010 4:33 PM , Blogger Avitable said...

And clearly, this is why I should get named Supreme Chancellor. No more debates.

 
At March 25, 2010 5:54 PM , Blogger B.E. Earl said...

Could've sworn that I commented here already. Maybe the government is cens...[ATTENTION: THE REST OF THIS COMMENT IS UNDER CONTENT REVIEW. THANK YOU FOR YOUR PATIENCE - THE GOVERNMENT]

 

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home